collection of pillows
Set of soft pillows isolated on white
Bed Basics

How a Pillow Fitting Can Improve Your Sleep

It can be frustrating (and flat-out no fun) to sleep on the right mattress and still not get the quality rest you need. But if your mattress isn’t the problem, what is?

There could be several reasons. A good place to start looking for the answer is your choice of pillow. Having the right one can dramatically—and scientifically—improve your sleep. Here, you’ll find out how a Mattress Firm Sleep Expert™ can match you up with the best pillow exclusively for you. And when you’ve got it? You’ll get your best rest ever*.

Before we get into the selection process, let’s start off with some science.

The science of pillow fitting: pillow choice and improving sleep

Mattress Firm has partnered with SleepScore Labs™ to add scientific approaches and data to what we do best—helping millions of customers sleep better to feel, and live, their best. Part of what we do together is conduct studies about different aspects of sleep. One of our recent studies focused on the Pillow Fitting service offered by Sleep Experts™ in our 2,400 stores nationwide. The goal of the service: Match customers with a pillow, based on personalized fit and optimal comfort, to improve their sleep. Were we doing it right? Yes. When customers compared the zzz’s they got with their new pillow against those from the one they had been using, they confirmed their sleep had improved.

Here are some of the takeaways:

  • With the right pillow, you can add up to eight hours of extra sleep every month
  • You’ll spend more time each night in deep, restorative sleep
  • Sleeping with the pillow selected with the help of our Sleep Experts™ can help you spend more time asleep, get more consistent sleep—and better sleep

Choosing a pillow with the help of our Sleep Experts™ doesn’t take a lot of time — you can find your match in just a few minutes. And it eliminates squeezing and smushing pillows in a department or discount store hoping one will be comfortable—let alone improve your sleep.

What’s the Sleep Expert™ process of finding the right pillow? Read on.

A pillow fitting can give you 8 more hours of sleep each month
Aneela Rashid

The pillow fitting process: what to expect

Your pillow has as much to do with improving the quality—and quantity—of sleep as your mattress. Remember: Your pillow represents about 25% of the surface you’re sleeping on. Plus, the right pillow is going to put—and keep—your head, neck, and spine in the best possible position to reduce pain and improve your sleep. Pillows matter!

When you come into one of our stores, tell your Sleep Expert™ what’s keeping you—or waking you—up. Don’t hold anything back. The more information you give the better your Sleep Expert™ can help. Need a few conversation starters? Describe the pillow you’re sleeping on. Talk about any aches and pains you experience. Tell them if you (or your sleep partner) snore. Whatever prevents you from getting a good night sleep, let them know.

The Pillow Fitting experience is going to be a two-way street. We spoke to Texas-based Sleep Expert™ John McCarty about how he guides guests through the pillow fitting experience. His questions include:

  • What position do you sleep in—on your side? Stomach? Back?
  • Do you experience neck or upper back pain while sleeping?
  • Have any concerns about pillow temperature? Do you sweat while sleeping?
  • How frequently do you find yourself having to fluff your pillow, smack it down or flip it over to find a comfortable height?
  • Do you have allergies? Do any other medical concerns hurt your sleep?
  • Have you slept on a pillow you loved? What made it so great?

As you answer, the wheels start turning in the heads of our Sleep Experts™. They use the details of your sleep habits and concerns to curate a selection of pillows suited for your needs. Since pillows aren’t one-size-fits-all, your Sleep Expert™ will suggest trying several options.

The selection at a pillow fitting

More than likely you’ll be given several pillows made of different fill materials and with different lofts to try out. One might be filled with down or down alternative. One could have memory foam, latex, or the newest grid technology. If you’re one of the millions of Americans who have trouble sleeping due to allergies? You’ll be given hypoallergenic options. Depending on your sleep position, pillows of different heights will be suggested to keep your neck and spine in the best position for sleep—and to reduce pain if you experience it. In short, the pillows you’ll be given to try will be the best options for you.

How to test your perfect pillow at a pillow fitting

You can’t judge a mattress by sitting on the side and bouncing up and down a few times. The same goes for your pillow: You can’t choose a game-changing pillow by squeezing or hugging it out. Your Sleep Expert™ will give your pillow options to you, each with a fresh, clean cover. Then they’ll suggest you lie down on a mattress, get in your normal sleep position, and get comfortable! That’s the best way to try out the pillows your Sleep Expert™ suggests.

The best way to test a pillow: relax and enjoy

OK, we get it. You might be hesitant to lie down to try out pillows in the store. Don’t be! Everyone—both customers and Sleep Experts™—is there for the same reason: better sleep. So, put concerns aside. Whatever you’re doing to test your pillows others might be doing in a few minutes (you might even be giving them pointers!). Plus, your Sleep Expert™ won’t hover over you while you’re weighing your options. He or she will give you space and all the time you need to make the right pillow choice. McCarty says it's worth spending several minutes on the pillow, lying as you would at home, to be sure that the alignment and filling feel right.

After you’ve narrowed your choices and picked your perfect pillow? Take it home and get ready for your best—scientifically proven—sleep ever.

*Based on 2021 pillow fitting study conducted by SleepScore Labs. Individual results may vary. The information on this site is not intended or implied to be a substitute for professional medical advice. Please consult a healthcare professional for any health condition.

You Might Also Like

Simmons Beautysleep Ever Firm Inflatable Express Air Mattress
Bed Basics
Why You Need an Air BedYour mattress is fit for royalty. Your spare bedroom is equipped with a comfy guest bed. Maybe you even have a daybed or futon in your home office or playroom. If it seems like you have all your sleep needs met, you’re probably wondering which other type of bed you’d ever need. Here’s three reasons why you need an air bed.
An illustration of a small bedroom with a well optimized set up.
Bed Basics
Small Bedroom? Here’s Your Guide to Maximizing SpaceFrom single dorm rooms to first apartments and historic homes, many bedrooms are smaller than we’d like. While we don’t always get a say in the size of our room, we (fortunately) do get to decide what to do with it.
Two sets of feet poking out from the covers of a bed
Bed Basics
The Best Cooling Mattresses for Hot SleepersGetting hot when you sleep is an all-too-common complaint. Hot sleeping is a top sleep disruptor, and anyone who’s woken up sweaty and kicking off the blankets understands how uncomfortable it can feel. Whether you suffer night sweats or hot flashes or you just run warm, there are many products that can help solve this nighttime discomfort. Here are some of the best cooling products to help hot sleepers feel relaxed and comfortable at night.
A woman sitting on her made bed, stretching her arms out in front of her.
Bed Basics
What Exactly Is Mattress Support?Perhaps one of the most common—albeit vague—pieces of advice you’ll often hear when you’re in the market for a new mattress is to find one with “good support.” But what does that even mean? And is mattress support the same as mattress firmness? If you’ve ever wondered what good mattress support actually implies and what the right support can do for your sleep, you’ve come to the right place.
A bed with a duvet, two pillows and a blue headboard in a white bedroom.
Bed Basics
How Long Does a Mattress Last? Think about how many years you have slept on your current mattress. How long has it been since you upgraded? If you’re struggling to find an answer, that may mean it has been too long. Even if your mattress looks like it’s holding up well, it may be time to start searching for your next bed.
the pros and cons of making your bed every morning
Bed Basics
To Make Your Bed… or NotWhen it comes to household chores, making your bed is the first decision of the day. Maybe you were required to make your bed as a child. But as an adult, you get the say in whether you'll tackle this daily task or skip it entirely. The question you might ask yourself is, does it make any difference in your life and wellness? The answer is, it depends.
A close up of a mattresses texture.
Bed Basics
Should You Flip Your Mattress?Your grandparents probably flipped their mattresses, but a lot has changed in mattress technology. So does that mean you should also flip your modern mattress? While many things from our grandparents’ era are worth keeping around (hello, best apple pie recipe ever) the notion that we have to flip our mattresses in order to keep them comfortable and extend their lifespan probably doesn’t apply to your current mattress.
side sleeper uses a pillow for more lumbar support
Bed Basics
What Is Lumbar Support and Why Do I Need It?Back pain affects a lot of people. In fact, it’s estimated that 8 out of every 10 Americans will experience back pain at some point in their lives. Luckily, our sleep experts are weighing in on ways to ease the discomfort.
A bed made with white bedding in a bedroom with an orange chair.
Bed Basics
A Sleep Expert's 6 Top Tips for Good Sleep A few lucky ones have no trouble sleeping, even in cramped airplane seats or lumpy hotel beds. The rest of us are familiar with junk sleep. We doomscroll into the wee hours. We awaken at 3 a.m. anxious to solve the world’s problems. We hit snooze repeatedly to try to feel rested.