Firm but Soft Mattress

Experience the perfect balance of comfort and support with a Firm but Soft Mattress. Designed for those who crave sturdy support without sacrificing a gentle, cushioned feel, these mattresses offer an ideal sleep solution for a wide range of preferences. Whether you’re looking to upgrade your bedroom or searching for that just-right blend of firmness and plushness, our selection makes it easy to find the mattress that suits your unique needs. Discover how a Firm but Soft Mattress can transform your nightly rest into a truly rejuvenating experience.

Show More

Sort & Filter

PressureSmart 2.0 Firm 11" Mattress

Beautyrest PressureSmart 2.0 Firm 11" Mattress

Starting at

Firm Comfort, best for

Back;Stomach Sleepers
Pain
Temperature
Bed Partner

FREE ADJUSTABLE BASE ³ up to $499 value with code ELEVATE (must add base to cart)

Basic Memory Foam Firm Mattress

Sleepy's Basic Memory Foam Firm Mattress

Starting at

Firm Comfort, best for

Back;Stomach Sleepers
Pain
Support
Temperature

Basic Innerspring Firm Mattress

Sleepy's Basic Innerspring Firm Mattress

Starting at

Firm Comfort, best for

Back;Stomach Sleepers
Pain

Rest Medium Innerspring Mattress

Sleepy's Rest Medium Innerspring Mattress

Starting at

Medium Comfort, best for

Back;Side;Stomach Sleepers
Pain

Rest Firm 2.0 Innerspring Mattress

Sleepy's Rest Firm 2.0 Innerspring Mattress

Starting at

Firm Comfort, best for

Back;Stomach Sleepers
Pain

iSeries 2.0 Hybrid 2000 12.5" Firm Mattress

Serta iSeries 2.0 Hybrid 2000 12.5" Firm Mattress

Starting at

Firm Comfort, best for

Back;Stomach Sleepers
Temperature
Bed Partner
Pain

FREE ADJUSTABLE BASE ³ up to 499 value with code ELEVATE (must add base to cart)

Basic Foam Mattress

Sleepy's Basic Foam Mattress

Starting at

Firm Comfort, best for

Back;Stomach Sleepers
Pain
Bed Partner

Greenwood 10.5" Firm Mattress

Beautyrest Greenwood 10.5" Firm Mattress

Starting at

Firm Comfort, best for

Back;Stomach Sleepers
Pain
Toss and Turn

FREE ADJUSTABLE BASE ³ up to $499 value with code ELEVATE (must add base to cart)

Perfect Sleeper Sleep Excellence Medium PillowTop Mattress

Serta Perfect Sleeper Sleep Excellence Medium PillowTop Mattress

Starting at

Medium Comfort, best for

Back;Side;Stomach Sleepers
Pain
Toss and Turn
Pain

FREE ADJUSTABLE BASE ³ up to $499 value with code ELEVATE (must add base to cart)

Estate 14.5" Firm Mattress

Stearns & Foster Estate 14.5" Firm Mattress

Starting at

Firm Comfort, best for

Back;Stomach Sleepers
Bed Partner
Pain
Temperature

Receive $300 Instant Gift⁴ with purchase.

Essentials Sudley 8.5" Firm Mattress

Sealy Essentials Sudley 8.5" Firm Mattress

Starting at

Firm Comfort, best for

Back;Stomach Sleepers
Pain

Original Mattress

Purple Original Mattress

Starting at

Medium Comfort, best for

Back;Side;Stomach Sleepers
Pain
Temperature
Allergies

MF 12.5" Firm Mattress

Pressuresmart MF 12.5" Firm Mattress

Starting at

Firm Comfort, best for

Back;Stomach Sleepers
Pain
Bed Partner
Temperature

FREE ADJUSTABLE BASE ³ up to $499 value with code ELEVATE (must add base to cart)

By Sealy Slumber Cushion Firm Mattress

Sleepy's By Sealy Slumber Cushion Firm Mattress

Starting at

Medium Comfort, best for

Back;Side;Stomach Sleepers
Bed Partner
Toss and Turn
Pain

FREE ADJUSTABLE BASE ³ up to $499 value with code ELEVATE (must add base to cart)

Lavender 6" Firm Memory Foam Mattress

Tulo Lavender 6" Firm Memory Foam Mattress

Starting at

Firm Comfort, best for

Back;Stomach Sleepers
Toss and Turn
Pain
Temperature

Essentials Winter Green 12" Medium Euro Top Mattress

Sealy Essentials Winter Green 12" Medium Euro Top Mattress

Starting at

Medium Comfort, best for

Back;Side;Stomach Sleepers
Pain
Allergies
Temperature

By Sealy Premium Memory Foam Mattress

Sleepy's By Sealy Premium Memory Foam Mattress

Starting at

Medium Comfort, best for

Back;Side;Stomach Sleepers
Pain
Bed Partner
Toss and Turn

FREE ADJUSTABLE BASE ³ up to $499 value with code ELEVATE (must add base to cart)

Perfect Sleeper Nurture Night 12" Firm Mattress

Serta Perfect Sleeper Nurture Night 12" Firm Mattress

Starting at

Firm Comfort, best for

Back;Stomach Sleepers
Pain
Bed Partner
Temperature

FREE ADJUSTABLE BASE ³ up to $499 value with code ELEVATE (must add base to cart)

Bamboo 6" Firm Green Tea Memory Foam Mattress

Tulo Bamboo 6" Firm Green Tea Memory Foam Mattress

Starting at

Firm Comfort, best for

Back;Stomach Sleepers
Toss and Turn
Pain
Temperature

Premier 13" Medium Memory Foam Mattress

Nectar Premier 13" Medium Memory Foam Mattress

Starting at

Medium Comfort, best for

Back;Side;Stomach Sleepers
Pain
Bed Partner
Temperature

Classic 12" Firm Memory Foam Mattress

Nectar Classic 12" Firm Memory Foam Mattress

Starting at

Firm Comfort, best for

Back;Stomach Sleepers
Pain
Bed Partner
Temperature

Essentials Spruce 5.5" Firm Mattress

Sealy Essentials Spruce 5.5" Firm Mattress

Starting at

Firm Comfort, best for

Back;Stomach Sleepers
Pain

Posturepedic Plus Hybrid High Point 14" Firm Mattress

Sealy Posturepedic Plus Hybrid High Point 14" Firm Mattress

Starting at

Firm Comfort, best for

Back;Stomach Sleepers
Pain
Bed Partner
Temperature

TEMPUR-ProAdapt 12" Firm Mattress

Tempur-Pedic TEMPUR-ProAdapt 12" Firm Mattress

Starting at

Firm Comfort, best for

Back;Stomach Sleepers
Pain
Bed Partner
Temperature

Receive $300 Instant Gift⁴ with purchase + Calm app 3-month free trial

TEMPUR-Adapt 11" Medium Mattress

Tempur-Pedic TEMPUR-Adapt 11" Medium Mattress

Starting at

Medium Comfort, best for

Back;Side;Stomach Sleepers
Pain
Bed Partner
Temperature

Receive $300 Instant Gift⁴ with purchase + Calm app 3-month free trial

TEMPUR-Adapt 11" Medium Hybrid Mattress

Tempur-Pedic TEMPUR-Adapt 11" Medium Hybrid Mattress

Starting at

Medium Comfort, best for

Back;Side;Stomach Sleepers
Pain
Bed Partner
Temperature

Receive $300 Instant Gift⁴ with purchase + Calm app 3-month free trial

Related Pages

Best Sellers

Signature Total Defense Mattress Protector

Sleepy's Signature Total Defense Mattress Protector

Starting at

Basic Adjustable Base

Sleepy's Basic Adjustable Base

Starting at

Signature Adjustable Base

Sleepy's Signature Adjustable Base

Starting at

Deluxe Comfort Cool Mattress Protector

Sleepy's Deluxe Comfort Cool Mattress Protector

Starting at

Basic Box Spring Foundation

Sleepy's Basic Box Spring Foundation

Starting at

Top Collections

Join today & enjoy an extra 15% off online or in-store

Loading footer...