Is My Mattress Too Soft

Wondering, “Is My Mattress Too Soft?” Learn how to recognize common signs of a mattress that may not provide the comfort and support you need, then explore options to help you find a sleep surface that feels just right.

Sort & Filter

Sleepy's By Sealy Memory Foam Medium Mattress

3489

Starting at

$779⁹⁹

Medium Comfort, best for

Back, Side, Stomach Sleepers
Pain
Bed Partner
Toss and Turn
Temperature

FREE ADJUSTABLE BASE ³ with code ELEVATE

Beautyrest PressureSmart 2.0 Firm 11" Mattress

Starting at

$774⁹⁹

$1549⁹⁹

$775 OFF

Firm Comfort, best for

Back, Stomach Sleepers
Temperature
Bed Partner
Pain
Toss and Turn

FREE ADJUSTABLE BASE ³ with code ELEVATE

Sleepy's Basic Memory Foam Firm Mattress

3221

Starting at

$249⁷⁷

$849⁹⁹

$600 OFF

Firm Comfort, best for

Back, Stomach Sleepers
Pain
Bed Partner
Temperature
Toss and Turn
Support

Sleepy's Basic Innerspring Firm Mattress

8687

Starting at

$249⁹⁹

Firm Comfort, best for

Back, Stomach Sleepers
Temperature
Pain
Bed Partner
Allergies
Toss and Turn

Beautyrest PressureSmart 2.0 Plush 11.75" Mattress

6252

Starting at

$774⁹⁹

$1549⁹⁹

$775 OFF

Plush Comfort, best for

Side Sleepers
Temperature
Bed Partner
Pain
Toss and Turn

FREE ADJUSTABLE BASE ³ with code ELEVATE

Sleepy's By Sealy Memory Foam Plush Mattress

2787

Starting at

$899⁹⁹

Plush Comfort, best for

Side Sleepers
Pain
Bed Partner
Toss and Turn
Temperature

FREE ADJUSTABLE BASE ³ with code ELEVATE

Sleepy's Rest Firm 2.0 Innerspring Mattress

7005

Starting at

$449⁹⁹

Firm Comfort, best for

Back, Stomach Sleepers
Pain
Bed Partner
Temperature
Toss and Turn

Sleepy's Basic Foam Mattress

1413

Starting at

$449⁹⁹

Firm Comfort, best for

Back, Stomach Sleepers
Pain
Temperature
Bed Partner
Toss and Turn

FREE ADJUSTABLE BASE ³ with code ELEVATE

Beautyrest PressureSmart 2.0 Plush Pillow Top 13.75" Mattress

2695

Starting at

$949⁹⁹

$1899⁹⁹

$950 OFF

Plush Comfort, best for

Side Sleepers
Temperature
Bed Partner
Pain
Toss and Turn

FREE ADJUSTABLE BASE ³ with code ELEVATE

Beautyrest Greenwood 10.5" Firm Mattress

3368

Starting at

$339⁷⁷

$849⁹⁹

$510 OFF

Firm Comfort, best for

Back, Stomach Sleepers
Pain
Toss and Turn
Temperature
Bed Partner

Beautyrest BR800 13.5" Plush Pillow Top Mattress

2788

Starting at

$1499⁹⁹

Plush Comfort, best for

Side Sleepers
Toss and Turn
Pain
Bed Partner
Temperature

FREE ADJUSTABLE BASE ³ with code ELEVATE

Beautyrest Silver BRS900 11.75" Extra Firm Mattress

3298

Starting at

$1399⁹⁹

Extra Firm Comfort, best for

Back, Stomach Sleepers
Temperature
Pain
Allergies
Bed Partner
Toss and Turn

FREE ADJUSTABLE BASE ³ with code ELEVATE

Beautyrest BR800 11.25" Firm Mattress

2235

Starting at

$1299⁹⁹

Firm Comfort, best for

Back, Stomach Sleepers
Toss and Turn
Pain
Bed Partner
Temperature

FREE ADJUSTABLE BASE ³ with code ELEVATE

Stearns & Foster Estate 14.5" Firm Mattress

1816

Starting at

$2149⁰⁰

$2449⁰⁰

$300 OFF

Firm Comfort, best for

Back, Stomach Sleepers
Pain
Bed Partner
Temperature
Allergies
Toss and Turn

Receive $300 Instant Gift⁴ with purchase.

Sealy Essentials Sudley 8.5" Firm Mattress

989

Starting at

$399⁹⁹

$799⁹⁹

$400 OFF

Firm Comfort, best for

Back, Stomach Sleepers
Pain
Temperature
Bed Partner
Toss and Turn

Beautyrest Silver BRS900-C 13.75" Extra Firm Mattress

1813

Starting at

$1999⁹⁹

Extra Firm Comfort, best for

Back, Stomach Sleepers
Temperature
Pain
Bed Partner
Toss and Turn

FREE ADJUSTABLE BASE ³ with code ELEVATE

Purple Original Mattress

59751

Starting at

$1760⁰⁰

$2199⁰⁰

$439 OFF

Medium Comfort, best for

Back, Side, Stomach Sleepers
Temperature
Pain
Bed Partner
Toss and Turn
Allergies

Sleepy's By Sealy Slumber Cushion Firm Mattress

303

Starting at

$1999⁹⁹

Medium Comfort, best for

Back, Side, Stomach Sleepers
Bed Partner
Toss and Turn
Pain
Temperature

FREE ADJUSTABLE BASE ³ with code ELEVATE

Beautyrest BR800 12" Plush Euro Top Mattress

737

Starting at

$1099⁹⁹

Plush Comfort, best for

Side Sleepers
Toss and Turn
Pain
Bed Partner
Temperature

FREE ADJUSTABLE BASE ³ with code ELEVATE

Tulo Lavender 6" Firm Memory Foam Mattress

217

Starting at

$182⁹⁹

$319⁹⁹

$137 OFF

Firm Comfort, best for

Back, Stomach Sleepers
Temperature
Pain
Bed Partner
Allergies
Toss and Turn

Sleepy's By Sealy Slumber Medium Mattress

176

Starting at

$439⁹⁹

$1429⁹⁹

$990 OFF

Medium Comfort, best for

Back, Side, Stomach Sleepers
Bed Partner
Toss and Turn
Pain
Temperature

FREE ADJUSTABLE BASE ³ with code ELEVATE

Serta Perfect Sleeper Nurture Night 12" Firm Mattress

1188

Starting at

$999⁰⁰

Firm Comfort, best for

Back, Stomach Sleepers
Pain
Bed Partner
Temperature
Toss and Turn

FREE ADJUSTABLE BASE ³ with code ELEVATE

Tulo Bamboo 6" Firm Green Tea Memory Foam Mattress

5565

Starting at

$259⁹⁹

$729⁹⁹

$470 OFF

Firm Comfort, best for

Back, Stomach Sleepers
Pain
Bed Partner
Temperature
Toss and Turn

Beautyrest Silver BRS900 12" Plush Mattress

1144

Starting at

$1699⁹⁹

Plush Comfort, best for

Side Sleepers
Temperature
Pain
Bed Partner
Toss and Turn

FREE ADJUSTABLE BASE ³ with code ELEVATE

Serta Perfect Sleeper Elkins III 11" Plush Euro Top Mattress

1610

Starting at

$599⁹⁹

$1199⁹⁹

$600 OFF

Plush Comfort, best for

Side Sleepers
Pain
Temperature
Toss and Turn
Bed Partner

FREE ADJUSTABLE BASE ³ with code ELEVATE

Nectar Classic 12" Firm Memory Foam Mattress

232

Starting at

$599⁰⁰

$949⁰⁰

$350 OFF

Firm Comfort, best for

Back, Stomach Sleepers
Pain
Bed Partner
Temperature
Toss and Turn

A mattress may be too soft if your body sinks deeply into the sleep surface, your hips and shoulders sit lower than the rest of your body or you regularly wake up with back pain, stiffness or soreness. A mattress that feels comfortable at bedtime can still lack the support needed to keep your spine in a neutral position throughout the night. Other common signs of a mattress that is too soft include difficulty changing positions, feeling trapped in the mattress, noticeable sagging and increased pressure on your hips or shoulders. Partners may also notice that movement transfers easily across the bed or that the mattress dips toward the center. Keep in mind that mattress firmness is subjective: a side sleeper may prefer a softer mattress for cushioning, while a stomach sleeper or heavier sleeper may need a firmer sleep surface to help prevent excessive sinking. To find out if your mattress is too soft, check for visible body impressions and lie in your usual sleep position with a partner or another person observing your alignment. Your spine should look relatively straight from your neck through your lower back rather than curving downward at the hips. You can also place a firm, supportive surface beneath the mattress temporarily to see whether additional support improves your comfort, but avoid using an unsafe or incompatible foundation. If your mattress is older, sagging or no longer providing consistent support, a new mattress with the right firmness level may be the best solution. Side sleepers often benefit from a medium or medium-soft mattress with pressure-relieving comfort, while back and stomach sleepers typically need medium-firm to firm support. Comparing mattress types, testing different firmness levels and choosing a compatible bed frame or foundation can help you get better zzz's and find a mattress that supports your sleep style.

How can I tell if my mattress is too soft + -

Your mattress may be too soft if your body sinks deeply, your hips or shoulders feel lower than the rest of your body, or it is difficult to change positions. You may also notice that the mattress feels less supportive when you sleep on your stomach or back.

What does a mattress that is too soft feel like + -

A mattress that is too soft can feel plush at first but may allow you to sink in more than you prefer. You might feel surrounded by the mattress, have trouble moving comfortably or notice uneven support across your body.

Is a soft mattress right for side sleepers + -

A softer mattress can appeal to side sleepers who prefer more cushioning around the shoulders and hips. The right feel depends on your body type, sleeping position and personal comfort preferences, so look for a balance of pressure-relieving cushioning and support.

Can a mattress topper make a soft mattress feel firmer + -

A firm mattress topper may change the surface feel of a soft mattress, although it cannot completely change the support structure underneath. Consider a topper made with firmer materials and a stable base for a more supportive feel.

How do I choose a firmer mattress if mine feels too soft + -

Compare mattresses by their firmness descriptions and materials, then consider how each one feels in your preferred sleeping position. A firmer comfort layer and supportive core may create a more stable surface, while a thin layer of cushioning can add comfort without feeling overly plush.