Is My Mattress Too Soft

Is My Mattress Too Soft is a common question for sleepers who wake up feeling achy, unsupported, or restless. The right mattress firmness plays a crucial role in ensuring quality sleep and promoting healthy spinal alignment. If you find yourself sinking too deeply into your bed or struggling to get comfortable at night, it may be time to evaluate whether your mattress is providing the support you need. Discover helpful tips and insights to determine if your mattress is too soft and learn how to achieve a more restful, rejuvenating sleep experience.

Sort & Filter

Sleepy's Basic Memory Foam Firm Mattress

3017

Starting at

$250⁷⁷

$850⁹⁹

$600 OFF

Firm Comfort, best for

Back;Stomach Sleepers
Pain;Bed Partner;Temperature;Toss and Turn
Support
Temperature

Sleepy's Basic Innerspring Firm Mattress

8550

Starting at

$220⁹⁹

Firm Comfort, best for

Back;Stomach Sleepers
Temperature;Pain;Bed Partner;Allergies;Toss and Turn

Beautyrest PressureSmart 2.0 Plush 11.75" Mattress

6239

Starting at

$775⁰⁰

$1550⁹⁹

$775 OFF

Plush Comfort, best for

Side Sleepers
Temperature;Bed Partner;Pain;Toss and Turn;Toss and Turn
Temperature
Bed Partner

FREE ADJUSTABLE BASE ³ with code ELEVATE

Sleepy's By Sealy Memory Foam Plush Mattress

2628

Starting at

$550⁹⁹

$1400⁹⁹

$850 OFF

Plush Comfort, best for

Side Sleepers
Pain;Bed Partner;Toss and Turn;Temperature
Bed Partner
Toss and Turn

FREE ADJUSTABLE BASE ³ with code ELEVATE

Sleepy's Rest Firm 2.0 Innerspring Mattress

6904

Starting at

$400⁹⁹

$1000⁹⁹

$600 OFF

Firm Comfort, best for

Back;Stomach Sleepers
Pain;Bed Partner;Temperature;Toss and Turn

Limited time deal ends Monday

Beautyrest PressureSmart 2.0 Plush Pillow Top 13.75" Mattress

2689

Starting at

$950⁰⁰

$1900⁹⁹

$950 OFF

Plush Comfort, best for

Side Sleepers
Temperature;Bed Partner;Pain;Toss and Turn;Toss and Turn
Temperature
Bed Partner

FREE ADJUSTABLE BASE ³ with code ELEVATE

Beautyrest BR800 13.5" Plush Pillow Top Mattress

2709

Starting at

$550⁹⁹

$1220⁹⁹

$670 OFF

Plush Comfort, best for

Side Sleepers
Toss and Turn;Pain;Bed Partner;Temperature
Pain
Bed Partner

FREE ADJUSTABLE BASE ³ with code ELEVATE

Beautyrest Silver BRS900 11.75" Extra Firm Mattress

3202

Starting at

$530⁹⁹

$1400⁹⁹

$870 OFF

Extra Firm Comfort, best for

Back;Stomach Sleepers
Temperature;Pain;Allergies;Bed Partner;Toss and Turn;Toss and Turn
Pain
Temperature

FREE ADJUSTABLE BASE ³ with code ELEVATE

Beautyrest BR800 11.25" Firm Mattress

2183

Starting at

$430⁹⁹

$1000⁹⁹

$570 OFF

Firm Comfort, best for

Back;Stomach Sleepers
Toss and Turn;Pain;Bed Partner;Temperature
Pain
Bed Partner

Stearns & Foster Estate 14.5" Firm Mattress

1635

Starting at

$2349⁰⁰

Firm Comfort, best for

Back;Stomach Sleepers
Pain;Bed Partner;Temperature;Allergies;Toss and Turn;Toss and Turn
Pain
Temperature

Receive $300 Instant Gift⁴ with purchase.

Sealy Essentials Sudley 8.5" Firm Mattress

989

Starting at

$400⁰⁰

$800⁹⁹

$400 OFF

Firm Comfort, best for

Back;Stomach Sleepers
Pain;Temperature;Bed Partner;Toss and Turn

Beautyrest Silver BRS900-C 13.75" Extra Firm Mattress

1742

Starting at

$805⁹⁹

$2000⁹⁹

$1195 OFF

Extra Firm Comfort, best for

Back;Stomach Sleepers
Temperature;Pain;Bed Partner;Toss and Turn;Toss and Turn
Pain
Temperature

FREE ADJUSTABLE BASE ³ with code ELEVATE

Sleepy's By Sealy Slumber Cushion Firm Mattress

271

Starting at

$560⁹⁹

$2000⁹⁹

$1440 OFF

Medium Comfort, best for

Back;Side;Stomach Sleepers
Bed Partner;Toss and Turn;Pain;Temperature
Toss and Turn
Pain

Beautyrest BR800 12" Plush Euro Top Mattress

692

Starting at

$420⁹⁹

$1100⁹⁹

$680 OFF

Plush Comfort, best for

Side Sleepers
Toss and Turn;Pain;Bed Partner;Temperature
Pain
Bed Partner

Tulo Lavender 6" Firm Memory Foam Mattress

217

Starting at

$350⁹⁹

Firm Comfort, best for

Back;Stomach Sleepers
Temperature;Pain;Bed Partner;Allergies;Toss and Turn
Pain
Temperature

Serta Perfect Sleeper Nurture Night 12" Firm Mattress

1099

Starting at

$800⁹⁹

$999⁰⁰

$199 OFF

Firm Comfort, best for

Back;Stomach Sleepers
Pain;Bed Partner;Temperature;Toss and Turn;Toss and Turn
Bed Partner
Temperature

FREE ADJUSTABLE BASE ³ with code ELEVATE

Tulo Bamboo 6" Firm Green Tea Memory Foam Mattress

5462

Starting at

$730⁹⁹

Firm Comfort, best for

Back;Stomach Sleepers
Pain;Bed Partner;Temperature;Toss and Turn
Pain
Temperature

FREE ADJUSTABLE BASE ³ with code ELEVATE

Beautyrest Silver BRS900 12" Plush Mattress

1087

Starting at

$680⁹⁹

$1700⁹⁹

$1020 OFF

Plush Comfort, best for

Side Sleepers
Temperature;Pain;Bed Partner;Toss and Turn;Toss and Turn
Pain
Temperature

FREE ADJUSTABLE BASE ³ with code ELEVATE

Serta Perfect Sleeper Elkins III 11" Plush Euro Top Mattress

1608

Starting at

$350⁹⁹

$730⁹⁹

$380 OFF

Plush Comfort, best for

Side Sleepers
Pain;Temperature;Toss and Turn;Bed Partner
Temperature
Toss and Turn

Nectar Classic 12" Firm Memory Foam Mattress

205

Starting at

$599⁰⁰

$949⁰⁰

$350 OFF

Firm Comfort, best for

Back;Stomach Sleepers
Pain;Bed Partner;Temperature;Toss and Turn
Bed Partner
Temperature

Serta Perfect Sleeper Elkins III 10" Firm Mattress

1572

Starting at

$381⁹⁹

$900⁹⁹

$519 OFF

Firm Comfort, best for

Back;Stomach Sleepers
Pain;Temperature;Toss and Turn;Bed Partner
Temperature
Toss and Turn

Serta Perfect Sleeper Oasis Sleep 12" Extra Firm Mattress

834

Starting at

$712⁹⁹

$949⁰⁰

$237 OFF

Extra Firm Comfort, best for

Back;Stomach Sleepers
Pain;Temperature;Bed Partner;Toss and Turn;Toss and Turn
Bed Partner
Temperature

FREE ADJUSTABLE BASE ³ with code ELEVATE

Sealy Essentials Spruce 5.5" Firm Mattress

1370

Starting at

$650⁹⁹

Firm Comfort, best for

Back;Stomach Sleepers
Pain;Temperature;Bed Partner;Toss and Turn

Tempur-Pedic TEMPUR-ProAdapt 2.0 12" Firm Mattress

4663

Starting at

$4099⁰⁰

Firm Comfort, best for

Back;Stomach Sleepers
Pain;Allergies;Bed Partner;Toss and Turn;Toss and Turn
Bed Partner
Temperature

Receive $300 Instant Gift⁴ with purchase + Calm app 3-month free trial

Tempur-Pedic TEMPUR-ProAdapt 2.0 12" Soft Mattress

3396

Starting at

$2899⁰⁰

Plush Comfort, best for

Side Sleepers
Pain;Allergies;Bed Partner;Toss and Turn;Toss and Turn
Bed Partner
Temperature

Receive $300 Instant Gift⁴ with purchase + Calm app 3-month free trial

Tempur-Pedic TEMPUR-LuxeAdapt 2.0 13" Medium Hybrid Mattress

2084

Starting at

$4199⁰⁰

Medium Comfort, best for

Back;Side;Stomach Sleepers
Pain;Temperature;Allergies;Bed Partner;Toss and Turn;Toss and Turn
Bed Partner
Temperature

Receive $300 Instant Gift⁴ with purchase + Calm app 3-month free trial

Is My Mattress Too Soft

Choosing the right mattress is a deeply personal decision, and it often becomes clear that your sleep surface may not be meeting your needs when you start waking up with aches, pains, or a lingering feeling of unrest. If you’ve ever found yourself sinking too deeply into your bed, struggling to get comfortable, or waking up with stiffness in your lower back or hips, it could be a sign that your mattress is too soft. Many people find that a mattress that feels plush and inviting at first can, over time, contribute to poor spinal alignment, especially if you sleep on your back or stomach. When your mattress doesn’t provide enough support, your spine can lose its natural curve, leading to muscle tension and restless nights. Some sleepers notice they feel “stuck” in their bed, making it difficult to change positions or get out of bed in the morning—classic signs that your bed is too soft for your body type or preferred sleep position.

As the seasons change and autumn approaches, it’s a good time to assess whether your current mattress is truly supporting your sleep health. Cooler nights often make us crave cozy, layered bedding, but it’s important that your mattress foundation remains supportive beneath those extra blankets. A mattress that is too soft can be especially problematic during this time of year, as the body’s need for restorative sleep increases with the demands of busy fall routines. For some, adding a firmer mattress topper or ensuring the mattress is placed on a supportive base can provide a quick fix, but these solutions may not address the root of the problem if the mattress itself lacks the necessary firmness. If you’re shopping for a new mattress, consider who will be using it. Back and stomach sleepers, as well as those who experience frequent back pain, often benefit from a firmer surface that keeps the spine aligned. On the other hand, side sleepers and lighter individuals may prefer a little more cushioning, but even they can experience discomfort if the bed is too soft. For couples, finding a balance that supports both partners can make all the difference in achieving uninterrupted, quality rest.

Mattresses that address the issue of excessive softness make thoughtful gifts for college students setting up their first apartments, newlyweds establishing their home, or anyone embarking on a new chapter where restful sleep is a priority. A supportive mattress can also be a meaningful gesture for loved ones recovering from injury or managing chronic pain, as the right firmness can help reduce pressure points and promote healing. When selecting a mattress, pay attention to how your body feels after a night’s sleep—if you’re tossing and turning, waking up sore, or feeling like you’re trapped in a sagging spot, it’s worth considering a firmer option. For those who still crave a touch of plushness without sacrificing support, hybrid options or mattresses that blend firmness with gentle cushioning can be ideal. To explore mattresses that strike this delicate balance, visit our Firm but Soft Mattress page for more information on sleep solutions that combine comfort and support. By investing in the right mattress, you can transform restless nights into rejuvenating sleep and wake up ready to embrace everything the season has to offer.